A Comparison Table of Dog Flea Products - PET SKINCARE FOR ITCH, PAW LICKING, TEAR STAINS & MORE

A Comparison Table of Dog Flea Products

There are various types of dog flea and tick repellants each with its own set of advantages, disadvantages, and potential risks. There are five types of dog flea and tick treatment products in the UK which include: topical spot-on treatments, oral medications, collars, sprays and shampoos and dips.

Always consult with a veterinarian before choosing a flea and tick repellant for your dog to ensure it's suitable for their age, weight, and health condition. It is important to monitor your dog for any adverse reactions after application and discontinue use if any concerns arise. Please be aware that there are cases of flea and tick treatments causing serious irreversible side effects and fatalities in some cases. 

1. Topical Spot-on Treatments

Examples: Frontline, Advantix, Bio Spot

Advantages:

  • Easy to apply.
  • Effective against fleas and ticks for several weeks.
  • Water-resistant formulations available.

Disadvantages:

  • May cause skin irritation or allergic reactions in some dogs.
  • Some dogs may dislike the feeling of the liquid on their skin.

Adverse Effects and Risks:

  • Skin irritation, redness, or itching at the application site.
  • In rare cases, more severe allergic reactions or neurological effects.
  • Some spot-on treatments are toxic to cats; precautions should be taken in multi-pet households.

2. Oral Medications

Examples: NexGard, Bravecto, Simparica

Advantages:

  • Easy to administer.
  • Effective against both fleas and ticks.
  • Lasts for several weeks.

Disadvantages:

  • May cause gastrointestinal upset in some dogs.
  • Some dogs may dislike the taste of the medication.

Adverse Effects and Risks:

  • Vomiting, diarrhea, or decreased appetite.
  • Neurological side effects, although rare.
  • Not suitable for dogs with certain health conditions; always consult with a veterinarian before administering.

3. Flea and Tick Collars

Examples: Seresto, Scalibor

Advantages:

  • Long-lasting protection (up to several months).
  • Water-resistant.

Disadvantages:

  • Some dogs may find them uncomfortable or irritating.
  • Not all collars are effective against both fleas and ticks.
  • Must be snugly fitted to ensure effectiveness, which can be tricky.

Adverse Effects and Risks:

  • Skin irritation or hair loss at the collar site.
  • Allergic reactions.
  • Some collars contain chemicals that can be toxic if ingested.

4. Flea and Tick Sprays

Examples: Adams Plus Flea & Tick Spray, Vet's Best Flea & Tick Spray

Advantages:

  • Can be effective for immediate relief.
  • Some sprays have natural ingredients.

Disadvantages:

  • Application can be messy.
  • May not provide long-lasting protection.
  • Some sprays have a strong odor.

Adverse Effects and Risks:

  • Skin irritation or allergic reactions.
  • Inhalation of spray can irritate respiratory system.
  • Some sprays contain chemicals that can be harmful if ingested.

5. Shampoos and Dips

Examples: Adams Plus Flea & Tick Shampoo, Vet-Kem Ovitrol Plus Flea & Tick Shampoo

Advantages:

  • Immediate relief from fleas and ticks.
  • Can be part of regular grooming routine.

Disadvantages:

  • Short-term effectiveness.
  • May require frequent bathing, which can dry out a dog's skin.

Adverse Effects and Risks:

  • Skin irritation or allergic reactions.
  • Overuse can lead to dry skin or coat.
  • Some shampoos and dips contain harsh chemicals; always follow label instructions and consult with a veterinarian.

Conclusion:

  • Topical Spot-on Treatments are convenient but may cause skin irritation.
  • Oral Medications are easy to administer and effective but can cause gastrointestinal upset.
  • Flea and Tick Collars provide long-lasting protection but can be uncomfortable and require proper fitting.
  • Flea and Tick Sprays offer immediate relief but can be messy and have strong odors.
  • Shampoos and Dips provide short-term relief and are part of grooming but may dry out the skin with frequent use.

Below are tables for each category of flea and tick repellants used in dogs:

1. Topical Spot-on Treatments

Feature Details
Examples Frontline Spot On, Advantix, Effipro
Active Drug Components Fipronil (Frontline), Imidacloprid/Permethrin (Advantix), Fipronil (Effipro)
Advantages Easy to apply, Effective for weeks, Water-resistant
Disadvantages Skin irritation, Liquid feeling disliked
Adverse Effects Skin irritation, Allergic reactions, Toxic to cats in multi-pet households

2. Oral Medications

Feature Details
Examples NexGard, Bravecto, Simparica
Active Drug Components Afoxolaner (NexGard), Fluralaner (Bravecto), Sarolaner (Simparica)
Advantages Easy to administer, Effective against both fleas and ticks, Lasts for weeks
Disadvantages Gastrointestinal upset, Unpleasant taste
Adverse Effects Vomiting, Diarrhea, Neurological side effects, Not suitable for certain health conditions

3. Flea and Tick Collars

Feature Details
Examples Seresto, Scalibor
Active Drug Components Flumethrin/Imidacloprid (Seresto), Deltamethrin (Scalibor)
Advantages Long-lasting protection, Water-resistant
Disadvantages Uncomfortable, Not effective for both fleas and ticks, Fitting required
Adverse Effects Skin irritation, Allergic reactions, Toxic if ingested

4. Flea and Tick Sprays

Feature Details
Examples Beaphar Fiprotec Spray, Frontline Spray
Active Drug Components Fipronil (Beaphar Fiprotec), Fipronil (Frontline)
Advantages Immediate relief, Some natural ingredients
Disadvantages Messy application, Short-term effectiveness, Strong odor
Adverse Effects Skin irritation, Respiratory irritation, Harmful if ingested

5. Shampoos and Dips

Feature Details
Examples Johnson's Veterinary Flea and Tick Shampoo, Beaphar Flea Shampoo
Active Drug Components Pyrethrin (Johnson's), Margosa Extract (Beaphar)
Advantages Immediate relief, Part of grooming routine
Disadvantages Short-term effectiveness, Drying effect on skin
Adverse Effects Skin irritation, Dry skin or coat, Harsh chemicals in some products
Back to blog